205 thoughts on “Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Review Leave a comment

  1. Here it goes, I have quite a few comments to make…excuse my spelling up front…..
    – The potions book in the Half Blood Prince that Harry uses which Harry discovers was 50 years old… Who was the original owner? Was it Voldemort’s? We learn that Snape’s mother was Eileen Prince and assume she may have handed it down to Snape. but that would make the book about 30-35 years old at best. So who owned it before that? Was Eileen Prince Snape an original follower of Voldemort? Was that a cause for the fighting between Snape’s parents? Did Lily have access to this book, possibly shared by Snape, which made her appear to be a natural at potion making to Slughorn? Also, I can’t believe that Harry (or Hermoine) would not recognize Snape’s handwriting after being his teacher for so many years.

    -In the Half Blood Prince Slughorn has an extreme, possibly inappropriate infatuation with Lily. She is “cheeky” perhaps which could perhaps be viewed as flirtatious towards him. When he too his Felix Felice potion at the age of 57, did his perfect day have anything to do with Lily? Was this the reason that Slughorn left Hogwarts as a teacher years ago? Did something inappropriate happen here? Clearly Dumbledore used Harry twice to pursuade Slughorn to a)come back to school to teach and b) to give him his Voldemort memory of explaining the horcruxes. Dumbledore was using Harry because he was Lily’s son and Dumbledore knew something that was never explained. Was Slughorn in love with Lily? He referred to her eyes way too many times to simply view them as wonderful eyes. He was obcessed with her eyes as if he was in love with her. It was mentioned numerous times throughout the book.

    – There is much more to Minerva McGonagal than has been devulged in these books. She is truely a magnificent character and if JK Rowlin wrote another book in this Harry Potter series I could see one explaining the history leading up to Harry Potter as an opportunity! McGonagal is about the same age as Dumbledore. She must have been a teacher of Voldemort if Slughorn was. Slughorn was younger than Dumbledore. She is Dumbledore’s right hand person and in the last book, is really in charge of many of the schools wonders – making the desks charge, commanding theiitems in the castle themselves. Voldemort prided himself on knowing the wonders of the castle – he couldn’t compare with Mcgonagal’s knowledge. She is head of Griffindor. She must have the qualifications – nerve, daring, chivalry, valor to have been appointed that position. How did she become a teacher? Was she a friend of Dumbledore’s when he fough Grinwald in 1940? Was she in school & in Griffendor with Agusta Longbottom who must have also been in this house. Was she in love with Dumbledore? She was very quick to tell Lupin (re:Tonks) “Dumbledore would have been happier than anybody to thing that there was a little more love in the world,” Said Professor McGonagall curtly, just as the hospital doors opened again and Hagrid walked in. (Half Blood Prince pg 624). Her loyalty to Dumbledore was absolute. Her scream at the end of Deathly Hallows when she though Harry was dead was striking – you would have thought the author would have made that agony sound from Ginny or Hermoine or Ron. But it was curiously striking that it came from McGonagal instead. ..”No! – The scream was the more terrible because he had never expected or dreamed that Professor MCGonagall could make such a sound.” (Deathly Hallows pg 730)

    -When Voldemort is killed, thos who were affliced by the Imperious Curse are released from it. How about those inflicted by the Crusio curse – Like Neville Longbottom’s parents?

    – What ever became of Belatrix’s Lestrange’s husband? She looks on Voldemort as a lover…what is going on here?

    – If Harry and Voldemort are both descendants of the Peverell brothers, they must be distantly related. The Gants (Voldemort) is also related to the Slytherin. Is Harry also related to him? To Godric Griffendor? To Dumbledore? What are Dumbledore & Harry’s genealogy?

    – How did the Sword of Griffendor get from the Lastrange Vault at Gringot’s bank, where Harry left it when they broke into the vault – back to Hogwarts for the final battle? We know the sorting hat was also once owned by Godric Griffendor. The hat brought the sword to Neville at Voldemort’s command. Why did the hat obey Voldemort? What about Harry’s agreement to give it back to the Goblins? The loop isn’t closed on this. What kind of flames engulfed Neville when Voldemort put the hat on his head, were they? They didn’t seem to harm Neville.

    – What happened to the Dursleys after they left the house in the Deathly Hallows?Were they chased by death eaters?

    – What is Harry’s career in the future? Is there a need any more for aurors?

    – What becomes of Hagrid and Madame Maxime? How did Dumbledore resolve the conflict between them when Madame Maxime refused to believe she was half giant?

    Why do the portraits talke and pictures don’t and why doesn’t Harry just get a portrait of his parents & Sirius and Dumbledore?

    – Molly Weasley – a very adept fighter….Where and how did she obtain the skills to kill Belatrix? Did she cas a silent Avada Kedavra curse when she said “You-Will-Never-Touch-Our-Children-again” giving her the split second advantage? How did Molly Weasley defeat Belatrix so quickly when no one else could?Ginny Weasley – her spells pack a powerful punch. Was this genetic?

  2. hey! i don’t get wy dey had 2 hav ron and hermione 2gever wy cant it b harry and hermione dey make a better couple. den neville could go wiv ginny and ron… well i dunno about ron he can stay a single pringle if he wants.

  3. When I read the first Harry Potter book, I thought Harry and Hermione would be a couple. Not because it was expected, but because it just feels right. There were many people saying: “Oh, the hero always get’s the girl!” But first Harry Potter it’s not a normal hero, he does not wear shinny clothes, he does not have big muscles, he does not have a brilliant intelligence. And second: Hermonie being with Ron it’s more a “cliché”. Why? Because Ron and Hrm are always teasing each other, so in a way they are more like brothers. I have two sisters and we were always “picking” on each other, but I would do anything to protect my sisters, the same could happen between Ron and Hrm. It seems that Jk thought if Harry and Hrm stayed together there would be no one for Ron. For me that was a big mistake. For those who read the books, they know that Hermione is the only constant thing in Harry´s life. In the Order of the Phoenix when Malfoy said to Harry: “I will stalk you like a dog” Hrm and Harry looked at each other and they immediately knew that Malfoy was talking about Sirius. Ron didn’t understand a thing. That kind of empathy happens only between couples. There are a lot of examples and it is very disappointing to me the end of the books.

    Bye

    Sorry for the English, but I am not an English man.

  4. I Love Harry Potter movies and the books, but I have one question.
    You have posted two pictures in you’re story.
    What is the second wone about?
    Please anwer my question!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *